Follow Grandma's Briefs

Search Grandma's Briefs
What do you think of this page?

Other places you'll find me writing:

Syndicated post on

 

 

Who's who on Grandma's Briefs

Folks you'll hear from (me) and about (them):

Jim (long-time hubby) and Lisa (me)

Brianna (oldest daughter) and Andrea (youngest daughter)Preston (son-in-law) and Megan (middle daughter)Bubby (grandson and coolest dude ever!)

 

 

Sponsor a Child in Jesus Name with Compassion

BlogWithIntegrity.com

Powered by Squarespace
« Just added to the Recipe Box | Main | 'Tis the season -- for spending! »
Tuesday
Nov102009

Of carp and kids' books

I often say in my postings that I'm unemployed. That's incorrect. I'm not really unemployed. As of this past August, I'm simply underemployed. I have a job -- a part-time job working for the local Children's Literacy Center as a site coordinator at a local elementary school. I just don't really think of it as a job; partially because it came about as an off-shoot of volunteer work I'd been doing since my layoff, partially because it's only 10 hours a week, and partially because I enjoy it so much that it just doesn't seem like a job.

One of the things I enjoy about the job -- in addition to the wonderful women who volunteer to tutor some really great kids -- is that I get to read kids' books, including picture books. I love picture books. I write picture books! None I've written have been published yet, but I have had a few close calls: personal letters from editors and agents, an honorable mention in the Writer's Digest Annual Writing Competition. I know that one day I will be published. It's just that I'm still in the phase of accumulating rejections, tweaking as each editor or agent suggests, only to be rejected again.

It's this continual rejection that makes me wonder how the hell one of the books among those in the small "library" I have for my tutors and students to choose from was ever published ... and mine aren't.

The book, "The Carp in the Bathtub" by Barbara Cohen, is one of the oddest stories for kids that I've ever read. It's Ms. Cohen's first book (written in 1972), so I'll forgive her a little, but I simply don't understand how she -- or a publisher -- could have seen this story line as something kids would enjoy.

Here's a bit of back story, then I'll share the parts that really floor me. The story is a first-person account from a young girl's point of view, telling about how her mom makes the best gefilte fish for Passover of anyone in town. The carp she uses for her fantastic recipe each year is housed in the family bathtub. The young girl and her brother, Harry, get attached to the fish -- and are devastated when Mom beats the poor carp to death and puts it in the meat grinder!

Here, take a look:

The kids loved the little carp. Now read what Mom does to their beloved pet (first page):

One year the kids kidnap the fish and hide it in the neighbor's bathtub. They get busted by Dad, they have to return the carp to Mom, who then clubs it to death, just like all the others. This is the conversation when the young girl asks Harry what happened:

That last sentence just floors me. This was traumatic! So traumatic that the writer, who obviously went through this as a child, was so deeply affected that she wrote a darn book about it!

But hey, Dad feels bad for his traumatized kiddos, so he brings home a stray cat for them:

A stray cat who CHASES THE RATS OUT OF THE KITCHEN! What kind of life were these children living? Sounds more like "The Glass Castle" than something kids should be reading!

I truly don't understand how "The Carp in the Bathtub" has made it into the hands of unsuspecting children ... and my "Hot Chocolate and Javelinas" still awaits acceptance.

PrintView Printer Friendly Version

EmailEmail Article to Friend

Reader Comments (10)

Too funny! You know, in a horrifying sort of way. It always amazes me to read old children's stories. Have you ever read the entire version of "The Spider and the Fly"? HOLY CRAP! No wonder kids were content back then to be "seen and not heard." I also, not too long ago, read the stories in the book that Michael Hague published - "Cinderella and other tales from Perrault." Beautiful illustrations but the stories are the stuff of nightmares. Kids sure had to be tough back then to survive the tales they were told.

November 10, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterAmber

Ok, first of all they feed the carp while taking a crap -- because going to the bathroom is a "wast of time." Then, there's a graphic depiction of Mom killing the beloved fish. I know it's the circle of life but holy carp!

I thought of "The Glass Castle," as well, Lisa. I think this would be a charming little reminiscence if it were in a book for adults!

November 10, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterPam

Crazy, huh! Maybe I'd be more successful if I made my javelina anthropomorphic, have him attack little children and pour the hot chocolate all over the rescue workers coming to save the javelina-ravaged kids, resulting in third-degree burns over the workers AND the kids! Sound a little more like what publishers might be looking for?

By the way, anyone who hasn't read The Glass Castle by Jeannette Walls should. It's a wonderful memoir, especially if you think your childhood was screwed up. Yours will seem easy-peasy compared to the wacky world she grew up in.

November 10, 2009 | Registered CommenterLisa

That's truly odd. It might be enough to make a kid go vegetarian.

November 10, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterKate

And I thought I had it so hard eating collard greens and cornbread for so many suppers but, at least Mother never had to beat anything to death for THAT meal! Yes, somebody had to kill the hog that provided bacon to flavor the collars but I never had to watch.

November 10, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterAnn

I just read The Glass Castle a couple of weeks ago, and yeah, those kids had a pretty f'ed up childhood. I also like the last line of the carp book, "Mama couldn't understand that." As in, she couldn't figure out why we'd name animals and get attached to them? Maybe Mama is a sociopath.

And Pam, I just made a "holy carp" joke in my most recent post, but I swear I read your comment after I posted it. I think we're both just geniuses who think alike.

November 10, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterHeather

Heather: I read your "holy carp" joke on your blog a couple hours ago and thought you were just riffing on Pam's joke! Yep, you're both geniuses!

November 10, 2009 | Registered CommenterLisa

Hey! I just bought the Glass Castle. May read it on my way to Oklahoma for Thanksgiving so that the craziness that ensues won't seem so bad in comparison.

November 11, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterAmber

Amber: I think you'll really enjoy The Glass Castle -- it'll put things into perspective before you gather round the holiday table for the mama drama!

November 11, 2009 | Registered CommenterLisa

I really did think my comment and Heather's post were just a cosmic coincidence connected by Lisa's post. Maybe it really is a HOLY carp.

November 11, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterPam
Comments for this entry have been disabled. Additional comments may not be added to this entry at this time.